Pif Magazine - ISSN: 1094-2726
editor's desk | email | submission guidelines | books and reviews | masthead | mediakit | writing contest | writers only

get pif's newsletter

enter your email address
for free monthly newsletter

search pif magazine


support pif magazine


help us continue to serve the arts and technology community online
Click Here to Help

The Best of Pif Off-line

Order your copy today



Pif Magazine
ISSN: 1094-2726

Pif Magazine
1426 Harvard Ave. #451
Seattle, WA 98122-3813

PAST FILM REVIEWS MORE FILM REVIEWS

The Passion of Joan of Arc (1928)
Directed by Carl-Theodor Dreyer
Reviewed by Nick Burton


find out more about this title

The Passion of Joan of Arc (1928)
Directed by Carl-Theodor Dreyer
Starring Maria Falconetti
DVD - $27.97
Not Rated

Danish director Carl Dreyer’s 1928 The Passion of Joan of Arc is one of those essential and seminal works of film art for which the appellation "masterpiece" seems inadequate. The DVD, put out by the Criterion Collection, gives the great silent film a new life. With the negative having been destroyed in a fire a long time ago, it looked like a good print of the film didn’t exist until one was unearthed in a closet in a Norwegian mental institution sometime in the '80s. A score, of sorts, was added in the form of Richard Eihnhorn’s gorgeous Latin oratorio, "Visions of Light," which appears on the DVD (complete with libretto that quotes Hildegard von Bingen) as an extra.

The story of the film is simplicity itself: Jeanne d’Arc is put on trial by "orthodox theologians and judges" in Rouen for heresy. (The film opens with a shot of the existing hand written documents of the trial that exist in the Chambre des Deputies in Paris.) Insisting that she was chosen by God to save France, the 19 year-old is told that she is, in fact, an envoy of Satan. When she tells them she will not dress like a woman until her mission is done, they threaten her with torture. Half crazed with fear, and finally threatened with the stake (after a bleeding, no less), Jeanne shakily and halfheartedly signs a confession of heresy. Jeanne is sentenced to life imprisonment, but before she is sent away, recants her testimony, telling her judges that her confession came solely from her fear of being burned alive at the stake, a fate to which she is then immediately sentenced . Outside, the people of Rouen engage the soldiers in a riot, insisting that a saint has been executed.

What makes this film remarkable in its execution is that the film is shot entirely in close-ups, the actors (whom Deyer would not let use any make-up) looking uncomfortably real in their austere, claustrophobic setting. Without a single wasted shot by cameraman Rudolph Mate (the film is an all too brief 82 minutes), the action of the film is impressively limited to the faces of the actors. One reads every wrinkle and crag on the faces of inquisitors Eugene Silvain and Maurice Schutz (who was also in Dreyer’s no less astonishing Vampyr), and one sees the sympathy on the face of the priest played by the poet/polemicist Antonin Artaud.

But it is the face of Maria Falconetti as Jeanne that gives this film its poetry. In her wide, watery eyes can be read the most rapturous faith and the most trembling fear. It is one of those amazing silent film performances that actually benefits form the lack of words — no words could ever be as eloquent as Falconetti’s haunted, unforgettable eyes. And don’t think because this is a silent film that you should expect an overwrought, corny performance; Falconetti’s acting stands with anyone’s from the sound era and surpasses most. The same goes for Dreyer’s flawless direction — there is nothing here, from the unconventional camera angles to the rapid editing of the finale, that looks anything but fresh.

Apart from Einhorn’s score, the DVD extras include a look at the great production design by Hermann Warm (the designer of the German Expressionist masterpiece, The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari), a detailed look at the various versions that have existed of the film (it was originally highly censored in France), and a fascinating audio reminiscence by Maria Falconetti’s sister Helene. If you are interested in film as an art form, this is an essential and unforgettable work.


Tell us what you think. Email talkback@pifmagazine.com

Want Pif to review your book?
See Review Suggestions for more details.


Nick Burton lives in Newport Beach, California. His fiction has appeared in many small press and web publications, including: Chronicles Of Fiction, Pauper, and of course Pif.

get a printer-friendly version of this page

© 1995 - 2009 Pif Magazine All rights reserved | Copyright Notice and Terms of Use | Preferences